Substitute for Butter in Pancakes
Best Substitutes
| Butter Substitute | Rating | Substitution Ratio for Pancakes | Ideal For | Flavor | Adjustments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Neutral oil (canola, vegetable, light olive, or avocado) | Best | 1:1 for melted butter in batter; 1–2 tsp to grease pan | Classic fluffy pancakes; dairy-free; even browning | Neutral, clean; lets vanilla/maple stand out | None needed. For richer flavor, add a small pinch of salt or extra 1/4 tsp vanilla. Medium heat for griddle. |
| Ghee (clarified butter), melted | Good | 1:1 | Rich, nutty flavor; extra browning and crisp edges | Deep buttery, toasty; no dairy solids | Lower griddle heat slightly; ghee browns fast. Use a thin film for greasing to prevent dark spots. |
| Coconut oil (refined or unrefined), melted | Good | 1:1 | Dairy-free; subtle coconut note; crisp edges | Refined is neutral; unrefined adds coconut aroma | Warm liquids slightly so oil doesn’t solidify. If batter thickens, whisk in 1–2 tsp milk. Medium heat to prevent over-browning. |
| Plant-based butter or margarine (80% fat) | Good | 1:1 melted or softened | Butter-like flavor with dairy-free option | Buttery; some brands slightly salty or emulsified | If salted, reduce added salt slightly. Rest batter 5 minutes to hydrate (emulsifiers hold extra water). Grease pan lightly to avoid smoking. |
| Greek yogurt or sour cream | Works | 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter + 1–2 tbsp oil | Extra tender, tangy pancakes; higher protein | Tangy, creamy; less buttery | Thin batter with 1–3 tbsp milk as needed. Cook on medium-low to set gently. Grease pan with a little oil. |
| Applesauce or mashed banana | Works | 1/2–3/4 cup per 1 cup butter + 2 tbsp oil | Lower-fat, fruit-forward pancakes; kid-friendly | Light apple/banana sweetness; less rich | Reduce sugar by 1–2 tbsp. Cook on medium-low and flip gently (batter is softer). Grease pan well to prevent sticking. |
What Bakers Say
Real bakers share what worked for them when replacing butter in pancakes — from substitution ratios to texture fixes.
Read baker experiences
"Using oil in the pan can 'fry' the batter so it doesn’t rise as much; several cooks got fluffier, more even browning by greasing only the first pancake with butter, then cooking the rest on a dry, preheated pan."
Reddit users in r/pancakes discussing greasy/wet pans and rise•home griddle pancakes"For super‑crisp edges without burning, some people mix a little neutral oil with butter (or switch to ghee) to raise the smoke point—oil for structure, butter for flavor."
Reddit users in r/AskCulinary and r/Cooking•greasing strategy on stovetop skillet"If your pancakes look blotchy or ‘spotted,’ try skipping fat in the pan; melted butter already in the batter plus a well‑heated nonstick or seasoned cast iron gave multiple users uniform golden color."
Reddit users in r/daddit, r/pancakes, r/Cooking•appearance/finish troubleshooting"Dropping batter directly onto a small pool of hot fat (oil or oil+butter) creates ‘mini shallow‑fry’ crisp rings and a tender center; too much oil makes them greasy and patchy, too little loses the crisp."
Reddit users in r/food and r/castiron•aiming for diner‑style crispy edges"Preheat the pan and add fat right before the batter—wait for butter to stop foaming or oil to shimmer. This cut sticking and burning, especially after the first two pancakes when the pan runs hotter."
Reddit users including a pro cook in r/Cooking•temperature and timing to prevent burnt outsides/raw centers
Choosing the Right Substitute
Butter in pancakes adds fat for tenderness, a little water for steam lift, and milk solids that brown on the griddle. When choosing a substitute, match the fat level to keep cakes fluffy, consider flavor (neutral vs. buttery vs. coconut), and manage browning and sticking on the pan. For batter swaps, 1:1 liquid fats are simplest; for lower-fat options, add a touch of oil and adjust consistency so the batter flows but isn’t runny.
Our Top Choice: Neutral Oil
Neutral oil seamlessly replaces melted butter in pancake batter at a 1:1 ratio and works perfectly for greasing the pan. You’ll get tender, evenly browned pancakes without changing the flavor profile. This is the most forgiving option across stovetops and griddles.
For Similar Flavor: Plant-Based Butter or Margarine
Choose a stick-style option around 80% fat for the closest butter-like taste and texture. Use it melted in the batter and for the pan; reduce added salt if the product is salted and let the batter sit briefly for consistent hydration.
Another Great Option: Coconut Oil
Melted coconut oil gives crisp edges and a pleasant aroma—refined for neutral flavor, unrefined for a coconut note. Keep liquids slightly warm so it doesn’t re-solidify; if the batter thickens, whisk in a splash of milk.
When You Want Extra Browning: Ghee
Ghee’s milk solids are removed, so it tolerates heat better yet still tastes richly buttery. It browns fast, so use a thin film on the pan and dial the heat down slightly for even color without scorching.
For Extra Tender, Tangy Cakes: Greek Yogurt or Sour Cream
These add moisture and a subtle tang but less fat, so pair with a little oil for tenderness. Thin the batter as needed and cook on slightly lower heat for a gentle set and plush texture.
In a Pinch: Applesauce or Mashed Banana
Great for lower-fat, fruit-forward pancakes, but they change flavor and make the crumb more cake-like. Add a bit of oil for softness, reduce sugar, and cook on medium-low to prevent sticking or tearing.
Have a Specific Question?
Ask our AI assistant about your specific substitution scenario
Try asking:
More Pancakes Substitutions
See all common ingredient substitutions for Pancakes
View all Pancakes substitutions