Substitute for Butter in Muffins
Best Substitutes
| Butter Substitute | Rating | Substitution Ratio for Muffins | Ideal For | Flavor | Adjustments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Neutral oil (canola, vegetable, light olive, avocado) | Best | 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter | Standard muffins, mix‑in heavy batters, extra‑moist crumb | Neutral; lets vanilla/fruit stand out | Optional: add 1–2 tbsp milk/water to replace butter’s water; no bake-time change |
| Plant-based (vegan) butter sticks | Good | 1:1 | Butter-forward flavors (vanilla, chocolate chip) and familiar taste | Very close to butter; depends on brand’s salt/flavor | Use stick, not tub; if salted, reduce recipe salt slightly |
| Refined coconut oil | Good | 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter | Banana, blueberry, carrot, tropical-leaning muffins | Refined is nearly neutral; unrefined adds coconut | Melt gently; keep batter ingredients at room temp to prevent re-solidifying |
| Full‑fat Greek yogurt (plain) | Works | 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter | Tangy muffins (lemon/blueberry) with tender, tight crumb | Subtle tang; richer than applesauce but less buttery | If batter is very thick, thin with 1–2 tbsp milk; do not overmix |
| Unsweetened applesauce | Works | 1 cup per 1 cup butter | Lower-fat, whole-grain, bran/spice muffins | Mild apple; less rich, more cake-like | Reduce sugar by 2–4 tbsp; expect slightly longer bake (2–5 min) |
What Bakers Say
Real bakers share what worked for them when replacing butter in muffins — from substitution ratios to texture fixes.
Read baker experiences
"A home baker aiming for ultra-moist double‑chocolate muffins ditched butter for oil and also mixed by hand instead of using a stand mixer; the next batch was a clear success and noticeably moister."
Reddit user (r/AskBaking)•keeping double chocolate chip muffins super moist"Several bakers report swapping melted butter 1:1 for oil in muffin recipes works, but the muffins tend to dry out faster over a day or two versus oil-based versions; avoid strongly flavored oils like olive oil."
Reddit users (r/AskBaking)•using butter instead of oil in an oil-based muffin recipe"Switching a bran muffin recipe from creamed butter to oil prevented curdling with buttermilk, made mixing simpler, and yielded muffins that were moister and stayed fresher longer."
Reddit user (r/Baking)•branmuffins with buttermilk curdling when using butter"For coconut oil subs, one baker recommends blending 1/4 coconut oil with 3/4 butter to keep tenderness without a greasy mouthfeel when making apple muffins."
Reddit user (r/AskBaking)•coconut oil in place of butter for apple muffins"Fans of a coconut‑oil muffin recipe noted it stayed moist but not greasy; when they tried the same formula with butter, the result was less impressive in texture."
Reddit users (r/seriouseats)•Stella Parks’ banana bread–style muffins
Choosing the Right Substitute
In muffins, fat softens gluten for tenderness, carries flavor, and balances moisture. Butter is ~80% fat and ~16–18% water; pure oils are 100% fat, so adjusting volume (and sometimes adding a splash of liquid) keeps the crumb moist without greasiness. Choose a substitute based on texture goals (moist vs. rich), flavor neutrality, and whether you need dairy-free or lower fat. Muffins use the quick-bread method, so liquid fats integrate easily without creaming.
Our Top Choice: Neutral Oil
Neutral oil reliably produces a plush, moist crumb and is the simplest swap in the muffin method. Use 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter; if your batter seems thick, add 1–2 tablespoons milk or water to replace butter’s lost water. This keeps flavor clean and texture tender without greasiness.
For Similar Flavor: Plant-Based Butter
Vegan butter sticks mimic dairy butter’s flavor and water content, making a near 1:1 swap that preserves familiar taste. Choose stick-style (around 80% fat) for best structure, and reduce added salt slightly if the butter is salted. Ideal when you want classic butter notes in vanilla or chocolate chip muffins.
Another Great Option: Refined Coconut Oil
Refined coconut oil gives a rich, tender crumb with minimal coconut flavor; use unrefined only if you want a coconut note. Swap at 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter and keep ingredients at room temperature so the oil doesn’t solidify in the batter. Especially nice in banana, blueberry, or carrot muffins.
When You Want Lower Fat: Unsweetened Applesauce
Applesauce adds moisture with minimal fat, yielding a cakier, softer crumb. Use 1:1, reduce sugar by 2–4 tablespoons to balance sweetness, and bake a few minutes longer if needed. Best in hearty, whole-grain, bran, or spice muffins where a lighter richness is acceptable.
For Added Protein and Tang: Full-Fat Greek Yogurt
Greek yogurt creates a tender, tight crumb with gentle tang—great in citrus or berry muffins. Use 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter and thin with a tablespoon or two of milk only if the batter is overly thick. Handle gently and avoid overmixing to prevent toughness.
Have a Specific Question?
Ask our AI assistant about your specific substitution scenario
Try asking:
More Muffins Substitutions
See all common ingredient substitutions for Muffins
View all Muffins substitutions